Skip to main content

Featured Post

Quick Tips for First Time Visitors at Walt Disney World

Post a Comment

The Problem With Shamrock Holdings

Taylor Swift's early music catalog was bought by Shamrock Holdings. For over a year, Taylor has  been trying to buy her master's, which include her first six recorded albums, music videos, and album artwork. She was denied the opportunity to buy them, only for them to be bought by Hollywood's most callous manager. Recently, the master's were sold again to Shamrock Holdings. 

A quick internet search will tell you that Shamrock Holdings is owned by none other than the Disney Family. Roy O. Disney founded the investment company and his granddaughter Abigail Disney is currently the Vice Chairman. Abigail Disney constantly speaks out against the Disney company's unethically greed and how current CEOs are not upholding Disney's morals. 

According to their website, "Shamrock's tenet's are straightforward - invest and act with integrity, responsibility, and transparency."

I have to laugh at the "integrity" part. Stealing another artist's work is far from moral. It is said that Shamrock Holdings is aggressive and launches hostile takeovers. 

I'm not going to sit here and pretend I know the ins and outs of the investment industry. I don't - it doesn't make any sense to me. But it doesn't matter. 

Artists deserve to own their own work.  End of story. That's all that matters.

Artists deserve to own their own work. 

The significance of the Disney family buying another artist's work without their permission is not lost on me. Walt himself was once in a very similar position as Taylor. In 1927, Walt found himself struggling to get his cartoon studio off the ground.  Producer Charles Mintz suggested that Walt create a character for Universal to distribute. So while Walt was working hard to create 26 Oswald cartoons, Mintz was secretly working for Universal and hiring Walt's animators out from under him. Oswald became a success, and Walt went to New York to negotiate a well-earned higher pay rate. To his surprise, Walt discovered that Mintz owned Oswald and that Universal could make Oswald cartoons with or without Walt. 

Universal may have legally owned Oswald - but he was Walt's. Walt created Oswald. Walt gave Oswald a life, a personality. Oswald is Walt's. The same could be said for Taylor Swift and her music. She wrote every single song in her discography. Her songs are her words, her melodies, her stories - all based on her life. But she is not in control of her own work. 

How can Abigail Disney, after knowing her great-uncle's history, buy another artist's work out from under them? How can Abigail Disney be an advocate against money-hungry companies and be part of such an unethical business decision? 

Shamrock Holdings made a very, very bad move. 

The only sliver of justice will come with Taylor Swift re-records all of her own music. Taylor Swift's fanbase has been sorely underestimated before, and the cynics were proven so wrong that it was embarrassing. After all, this is the same woman who continues to break her own album sales records with each one she releases. Her fans will buy the re-recorded ones and ditch the old ones. Taylor will sell her new songs to be used in commercials and movies and will continue to ignore any business deal pleas from Shamrock. Shamrock will NOT make any of their money back. And it will be what they deserve. 

If Taylor's path is to continue to replicate Walt's, she will own her art once again one day.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Complete List of Disney Animated Movies

 So, you want to know or watch every Disney animated movie ever? Disney Darling Blog has a comprehensive list of Disney movies, broken. down by the studio from which the films were produced.   Disney Animation Studios When most people think of "Disney movies", they are probably referring to Disney Animation Studios films. These movies were made from Disney's official animation studio and theatrically released.  At the time of writing, Disney Animation Studios (DAS) has released 61 movies. In this list, these movies are broken down by era. The Golden Era starts off with the massively successful Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. The movies in this era were critically acclaimed and helped establish Walt Disney as a serious filmmaker.  During WWII, the Disney movie studio struggled. To save money, many films were made up of a compilation of cartoon shorts. This era is referred to the Package Era, or sometimes the Wartime Era.  With the war over, D...
1 comment
Read more

A Review of Tinkerbell

One day my friends decided to Disney Bound as the fairies. They asked me which one I wanted to be and I had no clue. I had never seen a Tinkerbell / Fairies movie despite that the franchise was already 8 years old. But after a brief description of the fairies from my friends, I decided to go as Silvermist, the water fairy.  That was a year ago. Just recently I decided it was about time for me to check out this franchise. So I sat down and watched 2008's Tinkerbell. It was not as bad as I anticipated. Sure, there were some cheesy moments and the animation was crude. The movie's strong point was the voice acting of all the different characters. Tinkerbell has an all star cast with Kristen Chenoweth, Lucy Lui, Raven Simone and Jesse McCartney. Tinkerbell is voiced by none other than Mae Whitman. I am a big fan of Mae and she did not disappoint. I also really liked all the different characters, each with their unique talents and personalities. I think little girls could easil...
Post a Comment
Read more

5 Things I Will NEVER Do At Walt Disney World's Epcot

Epcot is a unique park to the Walt Disney World resort. There’s plenty of rides to ride, shows to watch, food to eat, and alcohol to be consumed. However, there are just some things that I choose to skip at Epcot. Here are the things that I will NEVER do at Epcot: Start in Mexico There is a great debate amongst Epcot fans: start in Canada or Mexico? I am firmly on team Canada. Mexico is a fabulous pavilion, and I like to end on a high note. Plus, the drunker you are, the more exponentially fun the Mexican boat ride is, so you have to save that for last. When it’s the Food and Wine Festival, I love starting in Canada to get some cheese soup first thing. I dream about that soup, and I don’t want to wait all day long to have it.  I also love starting in France from the International Gateway. As long as we don’t start in Mexico! Forget to thank the Phoenicians Did you know that the giant golf ball at Epcot has a ride inside? It’s called Spaceship Earth, and it’s the park centerpiece at...
Post a Comment
Read more

Are the Disney Princesses Good Role Models? Part 1: Snow White

The Disney Princesses are often topics of criticism. They are too weak, too focused on outwardly beauty, and offer nothing of substance to the world. This criticism is especially apparent in feminist circles. However, just like any other group of people bundled together under one label, there are disagreements.  If you ask a handful of  feminists their opinion on the Disney Princesses, you will get a handful of different answers. Why are the Disney Princesses even worth the attention of feminists? Walk into any Wal-Mart or Target or toy store and you will get the answer. The Disney Princess line is heavily marketed to young girls all across the world. And anything fed to the minds of the next generation while they’re still impressionable is worthy of examination. Whom these kids decide to emulate is whom they will become.  The Disney Princesses, of course, are not just limited to children. Disney movies span over decades and generations. Everyone, no matter the age, c...
1 comment
Read more